Carl Hubbell may not be a household name like Walter Johnson or Cy Young but he is a hall of famer, and he accumulated more than 250 wins while keeping his career ERA under 3. Also, he turned in one of the most impressive feats a hurler has ever accomplished in the 1934 All-Star Game.
1934 was quite a year for Carl Hubbell. He led the National League in ERA (2.30) Wins (25) and Saves (8). He was named an All-Star that year, as he was eight other times in his career. And what he did in that All-Star Game is the stuff of legend. Hubbell was named the starter for that game and he took the hill in familiar territory, the Polo Grounds, home of Hubbell’s New York Giants. His day got off to a pedestrian start, a single to Chas Gehringer and a walk to Heinie Manush, but he settled in to say the least. After the walk to Manush, Hubbell struck out Babe Ruth, no small feat as Ruth never had a 100 strikeout season. After Ruth came the Iron Horse, Lou Gehrig, Hubbell struck him out too (Gehrig never struck out more than 84 times in a single season). The story was the same when Jimmie Foxx came to the plate with 2 out. Hubbell struck out the side in the first in spectacular fashion; three of the most feared hitters in the history of the game. Hubbell was not finished though, he started the second by striking out Al Simmons and completed his feat by fanning Joe Cronin. That’s five hall of famers in a row, that was never done before Hubbell, and it hasn’t been done since.
How about some statistical context:
Babe Ruth may have been at the end of his career in 1934, but that career is likely the best a hitter has ever had. Though he only hit .288 in 1934 he was a career .342 hitter, good for 10th all-time. Ruth is also first all-time in career WAR.
Lou Gehrig had one of the best offensive seasons of all time in 1934. He won the American League triple crown that year, batting .363, hitting 49 HR and compiling 165 RBI. He did all that while striking out just 31 times in 690 plate appearances. Gehrig somehow finished 5th in AL MVP voting that year.
Jimmie Foxx was not too far behind Gehrig in ’34 he batted .334 with 44 HR and 130 RBI. Foxx also only struck out 75 times in 652 plate appearances.
Al Simmons was also a tremendous average hitter, hitting .344 in 1934 and striking out 58 times in 613 plate appearances.
Joe Cronin had a strange statistical year in 1934. He struck out just 28 times all year but he hit only .284, making his batting average on balls in play remarkably low, but that is beside the point. He was one of the toughest men in the American League to strike out that year.
On July 10, 1934 Hubbell struck out 5 batters in a row with a combined 2,218 HR, 9,386 RBI and all of whom batted over.300 for their career. All but Cronin batted over .325 for their career.
Hubbell was no slouch, he struck out 1677 batters in his Hall of Fame career, but none were more impressive than those 5 in a row in the ’34 All-Star Game.
One last fun note on the game, 17 of the 18 starters in the 1934 All-Star game are in the Baseball Hall of Fame, with Wally Berger being the only exception.
(The cards are from my collection, hence the terrible condition)


Steve
Stats gathered at http://www.baseball-reference.com/